by laurence kirk
•
20 October 2020
The biopsychosocial model of healthcare is not a new concept, and many osteopaths will be familiar with the work of Wadell and Main and their 'yellow flags ', and the potential effect of adverse 'mood' on patient recovery and prognosis. This contrasts with the effects described by Norman Cousins in his classic account of the 'healing power of comedy' Indeed, as long ago as 1911 one of the original osteopathic pioneers: Louisa Burns, was keen to research the physiological relationship between the mind and body. Ms Burns carried out a number of experimental studies and published the results. An excerpt is shown below, which although very much of its time, still poses some interesting questions. Nearly a 100 years later in 2010 Davis et al published the results of a study looking at the effects of Botox injections on the emotional experience. Participants were given positive and negative video clips to view (rather than the 'gloomy words' used in Burns' day) Those subjects who had received Botox were more affected by the negative video and more likely therefore, to be a little 'gloomy' as a consequence. So, an inability to engage facial muscles fully in response to external stimuli may have a direct effect on mood and potentially also on well being. L ouisa Burns Effects of Gloomy Ideas The blood pressure, pulse, respiratory movements, reaction time and dynamometer tests were taken, then words from one of the “gloomy” lists were pronounced, and the subject asked to give a synonym or related word in answer. Fifty words are usually about as much as the average person wishes to endure in such a test The results of these experiments may be grouped as follows: Blood pressure decreased, sometimes by thirty or forty mm., but usually ten or fifteen mm. of mercury. Pulse decreased, with occasional irregularities. Respiratory movements become irregular, sometimes with frequent sighings. Reaction time increased, sometimes almost doubled, for gloomy words; the usual increase is about .5 sec. per word. Dynamometer tests show decrease of strength of both hands, but especially the right, during and after the pronunciation and replies of the “gloomy” list. The gloomy lists are about as follows: • dark • forlorn • worry • pity • sorrow • labor • falter • hard • dull • silent • dying • moody • ill • stupid • sickness • failure • weak • fatal • peevish • restless • weight • shroud • torn • sleepy • dark • grave • worry • silly • mean • weeping • hopeless • false • blue • aches • heavy • frozen • sad • weary • broken • tomb • alone • poor • sorry • decay • faded • old • grief • timid A few people who were subject to slight hypochondria were employed as subjects. The gloomy list had not the least effect upon their physiological activities. Apparently the gloomy trend of thought is usual with them. Louisa Burns, M.S., D.O., D.Sc.O. 1911 Studies in the Osteopathic Sciences: The Physiology of Consciousness: Volume 3